Finding the safest neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie is one of the most important considerations for anyone moving to a new city, even in a calm and serene place like this. One of the first things you’ll want to look at is how safe it is for yourself and your family.
The city of Port St. Lucie is known to be one of the safest cities in Florida, ranking second out of 25 cities in Florida. This is a key reason why it has become a leading destination for all, whether for residence, a temporary stay, or simply to take in the sights. The city boasts a crime rate lower than most communities in the state, which is why if you’re considering a move, calling this city home may be a very safe idea – with only 1 crime per 1,000 residents.
However, as with any city, there are some good and some not-so-reputable areas within the city as well. Whether you’re moving to raise a family or enjoy some quiet time for yourself, there are some very safe neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie to lead a safe, peaceful lifestyle.
In this article, we will take a closer look at some of the safest neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie, to see which one is the best for you. We will consider the different neighborhoods in terms of their safety as well as the other relevant aspects to help you find your perfect place.
Sandpiper Bay
Sandpiper Bay is known not only for its scenic location along the St. Lucie River, but also for its reputation as a safe and welcoming neighborhood in Port St. Lucie. With a strong sense of community and a proactive approach to safety, Sandpiper Bay is an appealing option for those seeking a secure and peaceful place to live.
The neighborhood benefits from an active Community Patrol program, staffed by trained volunteers who work closely with local law enforcement. This initiative helps maintain a sense of security, with volunteers monitoring the area, reporting incidents, and assisting residents when needed. Additionally, the community's regular meetings keep residents informed and connected, contributing to a cooperative atmosphere.
Sandpiper Bay offers access to recreational amenities, including the Saints Golf Course and the Port St. Lucie Botanical Gardens. The area is very popular for its golf course communities, such as Ballantrae, and many of the properties that are on the courses even when they aren't in an HOA.
Residents also benefit from convenient access to shopping and dining, with Treasure Coast Square and local businesses just minutes away. Located near US-1, Sandpiper Bay offers easy travel to nearby towns like Stuart and Tradition, enhancing both convenience and connectivity.
With a variety of housing options—from older single-family homes to modern waterfront properties—Sandpiper Bay appeals to many different homebuyers. The combination of safety, amenities, and natural beauty makes it one of the most alluring and secure neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie.
Newport Isles
At the top of the list of the safest neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie is Newport Isles, a quiet gated community. It offers residents a perfect blend of convenience, comfort, and style – not to mention safety. With 764 homes that range from charming townhomes to expansive single-family homes, you’ll find options for your own lifestyle that are within your budget.
The Mediterranean-inspired architecture, solid CBS construction, and barrel-tile cement roofs add a touch of elegance to each property. Families especially love Newport Isles for its three major community pools, fitness center, and sports courts.
Sidewalks throughout this well-deserved safest neighborhood in Port St. Lucie make it easy to enjoy leisurely strolls, while the toddler pool and playgrounds offer plenty of entertainment for kids. Plus, with a manned gate, you’ll enjoy peace of mind knowing your community is secure. Its proximity to I-95 and the Florida Turnpike means you’re never far from shopping, dining, or a day trip to nearby cities.
Homes in Newport Isles come with plenty of perks: many boast pools, modernized kitchens, and beautiful lake views. With its rating of above-average safety from crime, the neighborhood stands tall as the safest neighborhood in Port St. Lucie, Florida.
St. James & St. Andrews Park
St. Andrews Park offers you several residential use options, including charming villas and townhomes in the community. Built with durable concrete construction, the homes in this gated neighborhood feature bright, cheerful stucco exteriors, impact windows, and plantation shutters for a timeless look. St. Andrews Preserve offers single-family homes in a safe setting right across the street.
Inside, you’ll find high ceilings, granite countertops, and stainless-steel appliances in most homes – and low maintenance fees. With spacious bedrooms, walk-in closets, and covered patios, these homes are designed for both comfort and functionality. The well-maintained amenities include a resort-style pool, fitness center, and lush walking trails, making this one of the best neighborhoods for families and professionals alike.
Centrally located, St. Andrews Park is near top-rated schools and the St. James Golf Club, offering easy access to recreation and convenience. HOA fees cover most utilities and maintenance, ensuring a worry-free lifestyle. The maintenance also includes a neighborhood watch and security guards, helping it earn a good standing in the list of safest neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie.
Gatlin Pines
Located just off I-95 and a straight shot (10 minutes) from the Port St. Lucie Police Department, Gatlin Pines is a family-friendly and secure community offering larger single-family homes and pool homes with open floor plans and modern designs. Compared to the rest of the city, it is a quiet, welcoming neighborhood where kids play outside and neighbors know each other by name.
Despite being a small community, almost anything you could ask for is within the community, ranging from vet clubs to the Seacoast Bank, McDonald’s, Walmart, a number of pre-and middle schools, and more. The nearby Sportsman’s Park and PopStroke offer a mix of recreational activities, and the area’s low crime rate and quick police response times make it one of the safest neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie.
Tradition
Located in Port St. Lucie, Tradition is a master-planned community designed for inclusiveness, wellness, and connection. Spanning over 500 acres of sparkling lakes and more than 300 acres of parks and nature preserves, it offers a perfect blend of natural beauty and modern amenities.
With carefully maintained neighborhoods, wide sidewalks, and abundant green spaces, Tradition is serene and the essence of family-friendly living. The constant patrols and the liveliness of the community make it one of the safest neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie. This safety is also one of the prime reasons why Tradition real estate is seeing constant growth in terms of value.
Bedford Park is considered one of the safest communities within Tradition, with everything you could ask for. It blends the small-town charm with modern conveniences perfectly. The community was designed and built by GHO Homes, featuring Key West, Coastal, and Low-Country architectural styles. There are also many 55-plus communities in the area for those searching for an active-adult lifestyle.
With 442 homes, Bedford Park provides plenty of options for you, whether you are alone or with family. The community’s excellent amenities include multiple pools, fitness centers, tennis courts, and even a gazebo for social events.
Just on the outskirts of Bedford Park, the Tradition Neighborhood Market offers residents a local gathering place for fresh produce, food, and unique goods from local vendors. Bedford Park, along with many Tradition neighborhoods, is also a gated community in Florida, keeping crime at bay with uniformed personnel manning the gates. The work ethic of these personnel and the overall low crime rate in the region are prime reasons why it is considered one of the safest neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie.
Hidden River Estates
Tucked along the St. Lucie River, Hidden River Estates offers residents a peaceful retreat with a touch of waterfront luxury. This quiet neighborhood features spacious homes with large yards, making it ideal for those seeking privacy and space.
Many properties also have private docks, offering the perfect setup for boating enthusiasts or those who enjoy fishing.
Hidden River Estates offers easy access to major highways, making commutes to Palm Beach Gardens or Lake Worth quick and easy. The nearby Town Center at St. Lucie West provides ample shopping, dining, and entertainment options. For families, the proximity to Sportsman’s Park and PopStroke offers plenty of recreational activities for kids and adults alike.
Despite having some of the most inviting waterfront homes in St. Port Lucie, it features a lot of security measures that make it one of the safest neighborhoods in the city, if not the state!
Fountainview
Fountainview is more of a commercial space than a residential one and the most suitable and safest neighborhood in Port St. Lucie for you if you are looking to set up an office in Port St. Lucie West. There are also condos and apartments in the immediate vicinity.
A 10,000-square-foot office building offers a premium location with I-95 frontage and high visibility from over 80,000 passing vehicles daily. It’s not just the hustle and bustle that makes it safe, though, but also the 24/7 security deployed there.
The building is fully occupied by professional tenants, including Morgan and Morgan Law Firm. With a newly built structure in 2024, this office offers modern amenities, multiple tenants, and long-term income potential with a 6% cap rate.
Fountainview combines quality construction with an ideal business location, making it a must-see for investors and businesses looking for prime office space in Port St. Lucie.
Final Thoughts
The police chief of Port St. Lucie, Florida, Chief Richard Del Toro, has been in the office since 2012. Throughout his career in the city, he has managed to uphold peace and serenity in the region, focusing on individual communities and the city as a whole. His efforts have directly led to the development of several safest neighborhoods in Port St. Lucie, making it a safe haven for families of all sizes.
When the city was announced as the second safest city in Florida, he mentioned in an interview that the survey was done before all the upgrades were made to the city. And sure enough, within a year, Port St. Lucie did end up ranking at the top of Florida’s safest big cities list.